Immerse yourselves in a culinary journey as we embark on a tour of the must-try seafood restaurants in Key West. This tropical paradise isn’t just about the breathtaking sunsets and vibrant nightlife, as it also offers a delectable smorgasbord of seafood options that will satisfy every palate. From luxurious dining spaces to quirky seaside shacks, we will guide you through a tantalizing array of fresh catches that make this Floridian island the ultimate seafood lover’s destination.
Half Shell Raw Bar
Overview of Half Shell Raw Bar
Located in the heart of Key West, Half Shell Raw Bar is one of those hidden gems that seafood lovers everywhere would be thrilled to discover. As a bustling local hotspot, it embodies the laid back Florida charm with its open-air vibe and waterfront location. With a history that’s as rich as its menu offerings, Half Shell saw its humble beginnings as a shrimp packing building and has since evolved into one of the most sought after seafood establishments in the area.
Seafood options at Half Shell Raw Bar
Beyond the traditional raw bar staples like oysters, clams, and shrimp, the Half Shell Raw Bar is known for introducing their guests to an array of mouth-watering dishes that never cease to impress. Among their notable items are the stone crab claws and the Lobster Ale house special, both of which have amassed a loyal following among locals and tourists alike.
Customer reviews and ratings
The reviews are a testament to the quality and consistency of Half Shell Raw Bar’s offerings. Customers rave about their delectable seafood, various options, and the refreshing atmosphere while awarding them high ratings for their outstanding service and unbeatable ambiance.
Conch Republic Seafood Company
Introduction to Conch Republic Seafood Company
History, flavor, and an unbeatable view, the Conch Republic Seafood Company has it all. Located in Key West’s Historic Seaport district, this establishment offers a delectable palette of flavors inspired by their namesake – the mighty Conch.
Menu highlights
Their menu is a tribute to the ‘Conch Republic,’ with items like Conch chowder, Cracked Conch, and Conch fritters. Their raw bar serves a myriad of choices including oysters, shrimp, and local specialties. But their menu isn’t just limited to seafood; they offer a range of options bound to satisfy any food lover.
Customer feedback
Renowned for its gorgeous waterfront location, tantalizing seafood, and top-notch service, Conch Republic Seafood has amassed rave reviews from satisfied customers. They’ve been lauded for their dedication to quality, with special mentions given to their lobster bisque and a fun atmosphere.
Hot Tin Roof
Description of Hot Tin Roof
Overlooking the breathtaking expanse of the Key West Harbor, Hot Tin Roof is an iconic dining destination that’s known for its unique take on seafood. Taking its name from a famous Tennessee Williams play, this restaurant infuses a fun and eclectic vibe into every corner.
Most popular seafood dishes
Notable items on the menu include their Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes and ‘Hot Tin Roof’ paella, each thoughtfully crafted with their signature blend of spices. Their seafood is locals sourced, adding freshness and authenticity to every bite.
Public’s viewpoint
Hot Tin Roof’s unique fusion of seafood flavors and vibrant ambiance has won accolades from patrons. Their exemplary service, stunning location, and unmatched variety have seen customers return time and time again, honoring them with high ratings and glowing testimonials.
Seven Fish
About Seven Fish
Tucked away from the bustle of Duval Street, Seven Fish is a quaint eatery, offering a calming escape with its cozy and intimate setting. Named after the limited yet exquisite seafood selection, this gem has become a go-to for people seeking quality seafood dishes.
Exotic seafood offerings
Their main draw is, obviously, the seafood entrees. These range from perennial favorites such as the renowned fish tacos, to the delicate flavors of the Thai-style shrimp curry. Their unpredictable daily specials are worth trying if you’re game for a culinary surprise.
Reviews from patrons
Seven Fish’s commitment to uncompromised quality and freshness reverberates through their glowing reviews. Patrons laud their extensive seafood palette and cozy atmosphere, often remarking upon the courteous staff and excellent service.
Alonzo’s Oyster Bar
Background of Alonzo’s Oyster Bar
Alonzo’s Oyster Bar, Key West’s first and only waterfront Oyster Bar, is a premier destination for seafood lovers. With a history spanning over two decades, this establishment knows a thing or two about delivering exceptional seafood experiences.
Seafood delicacies to try out
Alonzo’s prides itself on its oysters, offering multiple variations for the discerning seafood lover. From fried to steamed or raw, their oysters never disappoint. They also serve a selection of crab, lobster, and shrimp, making their menu an indulgent affair for any seafood aficionado.
Customers’ ratings and reviews
Alonzo’s has garnered high praise for its succulent oysters, varied menu, and unmatched views. Reviews highlight the restaurant’s consistent service, appealing ambiance, and fair pricing, making this beloved spot a must-visit in Key West.
Pepe’s Cafe
Overview of Pepe’s Cafe
Established in 1909, Pepe’s Cafe is renowned for being the oldest eating-house in Key West. With its old-school charm and nostalgic allure, this café offers more than just a meal – it provides a slice of Key West history.
Signature seafood servings
Serving an array of diner-style dishes, their standout is their flavorful and well-prepared seafood. From hearty bowls of clam chowder to generous portions of seared scallops or grilled swordfish, their menu showcases the bounty of Key West’s coastal waters.
Public reviews and feedback
The high ratings this café enjoys are the direct result of their delicious food, efficient service, and welcoming vibe. Be it for their seafood offerings, breakfast options, or the old-world charm, patrons shower Pepe’s Cafe with enthusiasm and high reviews.
Mattheessen’s
Introduction to Mattheessen’s
Mattheessen’s, found within Key West’s historic district, is a culinary treasure. Often mistaken for just a confectionery, this establishment has quickly positioned itself as a must-try seafood restaurant in the area.
Must-try seafood dishes
Their seafood dishes, though underrated, are among the finest in Key West. The crab bisque, mahi-mahi sandwich, and grilled shrimp are clear customer favorites for a reason – they are simply delicious.
Customers’ perspective
The consistent praise for Mattheessen’s showcases its quality. Customers leave rave reviews for not only their food but also their exceptional service and excellent prices. They particularly applaud the restaurant for its tasty seafood dishes and prompt service.
Blue Heaven
Details about Blue Heaven
A vibrant eatery set in a tropical courtyard, Blue Heaven is an earthly paradise of flavors. Famous for its vibrant ambiance, outdoor dining, it’s a seafood heaven in Key West.
Popular seafood menu items
Their menu, heavily influenced by Caribbean, and American cuisines, boasts a plethora of seafood choices. The Caribbean shrimp deglazed with red stripe beer and the snapper served on jasmine rice are to die for.
Customers’ reviews and ratings
With rave reviews and high ratings, Blue Heaven is adored by its patrons. The restaurant receives consistent appreciation for its charming setup, excellent food quality, and distinctive seafood offerings, making it a popular must-visit stop in Key West.
Latitudes
Background of Latitudes
Latitudes, set on the private island of Sunset Key, provides a dining experience unlike any other. Its luxurious ambiance and exquisite cuisine make it the perfect dining destination for those seeking a combination of great food and memorable experiences.
Seafood feast at Latitudes
Latitudes offers an unforgettable seafood spread, featuring dishes made from the freshest locally sourced sea fare. The Lobster Bisque and Key West Pink Shrimp are standout options that never fail to enchant the taste buds.
Public’s viewpoint
From the stunning location to the delectable cuisine, Latitudes has won the hearts of many. With high ratings and encouraging reviews, customers frequently applaud the diverse seafood options, striking setting, and attentive service.
Santiago’s Bodega
About Santiago’s Bodega
Nestled in a quaint and cozy corner of Key West, located at 207 Petronia Street, Santiago’s Bodega is a vibrant tapas bar that offers a delightful array of seafood dishes. Its colorful decor and intimate atmosphere create a welcoming space for diners looking for something a little different.
Varieties of seafood delicacies
Their menu offers a wonderful variety of seafood tapas designed to surprise and delight. The Pan Seared Scallops and the Smoked Salmon Dip stand out as particularly tantalizing offerings that are a must-try.
Patrons’ feedback and ratings
Santiago’s Bodega enjoys a lot of love from its patrons, who applaud the peerless combination of sumptuous seafood, ambient setting, and attentive service. The positive feedback and high ratings reflect the quality and thoughtful lineup of this charming tapas bar.
